20070930 : 1:02 AM
http://img517.imageshack.us/img517/879/toounitphailsgf1.jpg
after seeing this, i really don't know what to say.
damn i really thought his techniques and stuff were pretty damn good, and now this sort of scandal turns up. i guess it's kinda of a letdown and stuff. i saw Genesis in July, guess i should be relieved i didn't buy it. D:
quote from a certain Deviant's journal:
1. "Toounit's artwork is heavily referenced - from character design, clothing design, to background and composition designs." He never actually comes out and says that he's referenced things, only says "inspired." However, there are a few things (very few) in his gallery or have been in his gallery that I still think are original (there's hope for this kid!) such as his daily deviation... (how ironic..).
2. "Toounit has become worshipped and even became and icon of the anime/manga style in Malaysia." I myself even thought he was amazing. I mean, come on... age 18 and so successful? It was quite a sight, and everyone had envy, and I think I'm assuming correctly. Therefore the shock that comes from this ugly truth is very large. It's not something we all go through everyday. It's a combination of feeling disappointment, let down, and betrayal. It's an ugly feeling, and though telling people the truth would be honorable, I still think if we could, we should avoid making people feel those ugly feelings.
3. "Toounit has sold artbooks of his heavily referenced work." And people bought it. It's crossing the moral boundary somewhere... but it's legal, I bet. I don't think we could do anything about that... except a lot of people might boycott his artbook. He has also auctioned/sold his artwork.. but I don't think that would stop people from buying his work. Despite his unoriginality, I think I would have still bought his artbook (I know, how unloyal I am! D: )
4. "Toounit works for an illustration/publishing company." In all honesty, I think this is one of toounit's fibs. He claims to have submitted tutorials and pieces for Asukashinsa's SS (aka Small S/Sky S/Bessatsu SS) and S magazines, as well as doing work for fujimishobo and Korean novels. If you've looked at any of those websites, you won't see anything about toounit in sight.
5. "Toounit, though unoriginal as he is, still has a lot of talent." I'm not so sure we can use the word talent, but I must say he has a lot of technical skill. He has a very powerful coloring technique that I don't think many of us can say is horrible. And he's taught us things about this: he's submitted numerous tutorials and answered questions. Despite how angry at him I am right now, I can't deny that I've learned a lot of things from that twit.
Another quote from another Deviant's journal:
Fan art Art that is drawn based on an existing character, story, design, costume or any media, that is not drawn by the artist itself. Usually drawn as a tribute, or as a way of showing love to certain fandoms.
Reference Art that is based on something that can be seen. Usually drawn for the purpose of studying arts and objects. Doesnt nessesary have to look exactly like the original.
Inspiration Art that is influenced by something. Can be seen or things that cannot be seen. Usually drawn when getting certain impact, such as an artist is inspired to draw something emo when listening to some music/event/etc
Copying Reconstruct or reproducting something that is original. What made copying and reference different is that, copying, is copying everything from the original. Colours, design, composition, angle, toning, concept, shadows, style, etc. While referencing, is just drawing the object, but some part can be original, something that is created by the artist.
Nope. This is not what I think up. I did some research LOL.
But what I write below is what I think.
I think, sometimes fanart can be original too. There is no right or wrong drawing them. For example, if I like Naruto, I can draw a drawing of Naruto, with different concept/style. Since i think of the composition/design/etc by my own, while using Naruto as the character in the art, I can still draw it out and claim it as fanart.
But if, lets say, I saw the drawing of Naruto by the original artist, and I like it, and I redraw it. I can call it fanart, but, it's mere copying. I can share with my friends, but I can't sell it, since eventho I use my strength to draw it, it is originally belongs to the artist. The strength belongs to him. He is the one who think of the direction of the art.
Let's talk about original arts then. I read the newspaper. There's this case of a girl and it touched me and made me sad. So I wanted to draw something, because I am inspired. Or I saw this cool pattern on the floor. I am like, whoa, fantastic! What if I draw it out for this piece? So I draw this drawing, while having the patttern in my mind, and applied it on my drawing.
What if, I saw this picture on the magazine. Cool! I want to draw something like that. But in the end, what I draw, end up looks exactly like the magazine. Dang. What if I put another element from another magazine? In the end, the picture looks like a combination of two magazines, exactly like them. Dang. I think I just copied. This is not original! I can share this thing with friends, but I can't sell it off, because it is someone else's hardwork and dedication. All I did is just copying.
That's my opinion. I am not sure about anyone else. I used to copy works, but that was when I was learning. Like, I draw a drawing of Rurouni Kenshin that looks exactly like it. And several years later I start to imagine whatever things that I want to draw. It's kinda hard. It's VERY hard. Because I used to copy so much, and I have to start thinking independantly. Because I have to spend my time thinking, planning, executing and whatnot, without looking at anything. Because I am the type of person that will be very paranoid if my drawings look like someone else. And I will start to blame myself being so flawfull. And then I emo hahhaa......
But anyways! Regardless of whether you're in DA/SA/whatever art galleries/whatever place. Do you have a proper ettiquette as an artist?
|
the round one.
Just your average human specimen wanting to be something more.
Also has an absurd fondness for potatoes and shoes, among other things.
what i want.
(these are clickable nudge nudge)
bicycle!!!1!
PLAYSTATION3
tv/HD screen for PS3
POP OP figures
sutadora figure
ps1 (not the console)
幸せ / きらめき / 自由
AMAZON WISHLIST
html ref from dougnutcrazy
|